Get This Free Cheat Sheet Guaranteed To Help Your Next Mix

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Busting Some Soundproofing Myths

Before you can look at some accepted ways to improve your isolation, it’s important to look at all the things that won’t work. In this excerpt from The Studio Builder’s Handbook (written with Dennis Moody) is a list of various materials that you’ll often see attached to the walls of a space in hopes of increasing the isolation, but although they won't help very much at all.
  • Mattresses - There are so many things wrong with this that it’s hard to know where to start. Sure mattresses are made up of a lot of soft material, but it’s not the right kind for sound absorption, won’t affect the low frequencies at all (which are what causes most of the the isolation problems), accumulates mold and moisture, and makes nice homes for rodents and other unwanted critters. Plus, it’s pretty difficult to get enough of them to cover a room, and they take up so much space for so little benefit in return.
  • Egg Crates - Egg crates are light porous cardboard and do absolutely nothing for soundproofing. They can act as a sound diffusor at higher frequencies, but the bandwidth is so limited that they’re virtually useless there as well. Plus, they're highly flammable! It’s difficult to find enough of them to cover a room, but frankly, even using one is too many.
  • Carpet - Carpet attached to the wall is another product that will affect the sound of the room yet do nothing in the way of soundproofing since it doesn’t affect the low frequencies, which are the ones that you’ve got to control for good isolation. Carpet has exactly the same problem as mattresses in that it will begin to smell over time. Old or new carpet makes no difference, except that older carpet will smell more.
  • Foam Rubber - Foam rubber does have some acoustical absorption properties, but once again will do very little for the low frequencies that will cause all of your problems with the neighbors. It’s can be as expensive as materials with real acoustic control properties, degrades over time, and will burn like crazy if given the chance.
  • Rubber - Floor matts, mouse pads, neoprene, or any other variation of rubber will do very little to stop sound coming or going from your room. Once again, it’s much cheaper to buy proper acoustic materials that are easier to work with, but they won’t help your isolation problem either.
  • Wall Cellulose - Pumping cellulose insulation into walls can make a slight difference, but it’s marginal since there are much more effective ways to improve the isolation that are much cheaper. It can be helpful if used along with some other techniques that we’ll soon go over, but isn’t particularly effective by itself.
  • Fiberglass Insulation - Common fiberglass insulation once again has little ability to stop enough of the low frequencies that bug your neighbors, although, like with blown cellulose, it can be useful in conjunction with other techniques. Just pinning it to the wall won’t help though, but it will affect the acoustics of the room. It’s also a skin and eye irritant, takes up a lot of space, and the dust can be hazardous to your lungs when left exposed. As you’ll soon see, there’s a much better way to use fiberglass for acoustic control (although it still won’t help with isolation much).
  • Plywood Panels - It’s true that plywood panels provide mass and mass is what’s needed to stop sound transmission (especially the low frequencies), but the problem is that wood transfers sound too well so the construction technique used is crucial. Not only that, if the panels are too thin they’ll resonate and vibrate, causing an even bigger problem.
  • Particle Board - See plywood panels.
  • Bales Of Hay - Unless you live out in the country, it’s unlikely that hay bales are much of an option, but they actually do work. The problem is that they take up a lot of usable space, make a nice home for critters, and are a major fire hazard. Not recommended
  • Acoustic Foam - Acoustic foam is helpful in controlling the acoustics within a room, but it does nothing to stop sound transmission and is expensive to boot. Acoustic foam doesn’t even begin to affect the offending low frequencies, and using too much just makes the room seem dead and uncomfortable. There are much cheaper ways to achieve a better result.
Understand that all of these materials will have at least some affect on the sound of the room (which we’ll cover later in the chapter), but will do almost nothing by themselves to help improve your isolation.

You should follow me on Twitter for daily news and updates on production and the music business.

Don't forget to check out my Music 3.0 blog for tips and tricks on navigating the music business.


Peter said...

Bobby, you are a king. I learn more useful information from your blog that from anything else I read! Thanks..

Peter in Oakland CA

Samual James said...

Really beneficial post. Many people are in search for such a soundproofing technique, and they have to be, because noise pollution has became a big problem nowaday. Thanks a lot for providing this information about insonorizacion

Jeff said...

Thanks for debunking these "urban soundproofing myths". It's amazing how the wrong ideas are passed along to so many people!

Neal Mayhem said...

Thank you for posting this! It's so irritating to see so many people wasting their time with pointless home sound proofing. If it was this easy to sound proof a studio, more people would be doing it.

It took me three years to learn that the duvets and egg crates I had up in my first home studio were doing nothing for my sound.

It's well worth doing some research and making your own soundproofing, but with proper materials.

soundproofing ceilings said...

I got here great list of products which are really useful to reduce sound.

Frank Alexander said...

thanks for Your posting Blog This!
Acoustic Insulation

sudarshan shankar said...

Nice post. Thanks for sharing this blog. We also Manufacturers of Acoustic Wadding Acoustic Wadding Manufacturers

Kath Morgan said...

We use neither eggs nor overpriced foam. But in our country some people still use eggs cartoons and try to convince others that this is good treatment.

We have the best In Home insulation installers Adelaide

Nick Collins said...

Great advice, have been looking at several solutions, several people have recommended soundproofing materials from Acara. Which aslo looks good.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...